Blog

Home / Blog / 108 Years on One Shoreline: The History of Fillenwarth Beach
Fillenwarth's Beach Cottages advertisement from 1930, Arnolds Park, West Lake Okoboji

108 Years on One Shoreline: The History of Fillenwarth Beach

Fillenwarth Beach is a family resort on West Lake Okoboji in Arnolds Park, Iowa, run by the same family since A.T. Fillenwarth, a Sanborn lawyer, built a single cottage here around 1918. He rented it to a stranger for a week, then kept building, and by 1930 he had 36 cottages. His son Ken, born on the property in 1924, ran it until his death in 2014, and Ken’s daughter Lynn runs it now. A tornado on June 13, 1968 flattened most of the Main Beach cottages, and most of what stands on the Main Beach today went up after it. Two buildings survived: the 1966 office and the first cottage, Old Faithful, which is now the indoor pool.

Key Takeaways

  • Three generations: A.T. and Sadie, their son Ken, and Ken’s daughter Lynn.
  • Three founding years are in print, 1917, 1918 and 1919. The family uses 1918.
  • The June 13, 1968 tornado left only the office and Old Faithful standing on the Main Beach.
  • South Beach was the Parkview Motel, which the same tornado also hit. Cottage Colony was a separate resort until 1978.
  • Sun Runner II started life as the boat builder’s own boat, the Suwannee.

When did Fillenwarth Beach actually start?

We say 1918. Our FAQ says “1918 or 1919 (none of us were alive then),” which is the more honest answer, and the printed record does not settle it.

Our History page has A.T. buying the land and building the family cottage in 1918. A 2024 profile of Lynn in Okoboji Magazine puts it at 1919, and so does a Sioux City Journal piece that interviewed Ken. Then there is A.T.’s own entry in the 1940 edition of Who’s Who in Iowa, which lists him as owner and operator of “Fillenwarth Modern Beach Cottages” from 1917. Three dates, none of them agreeing.

Our guess is that the land and the first paying guest arrived in different years. We use 1918 because it is the year on our History page, and because a resort that changed its founding date in its second century would have some explaining to do.

The rest of A.T.’s record is less slippery. Arthur T. Fillenwarth was born in 1887, took his law degree at the University of Iowa in 1912, married Sadie Raecker in 1913 and opened a practice in Sanborn the same year. The 1913 Sanborn business directory, printed in the 1914 history of O’Brien and Osceola counties, lists him as an attorney. By 1940 he gave his occupation as “Attorney & Operator Summer Resort,” in that order.

How did one family cottage become 36?

By accident, more or less. The first cottage had no windows, only awnings and screens over the openings, and the family called it Old Faithful. Then a man came by and offered to rent it for a week. A.T. took the money and moved his family back to Sanborn for the week. Ken, asked about it decades later, put his father’s reasoning plainly: “He couldn’t afford not to take that money.”

More offers followed, so A.T. built rental cottages in the early 1920s, this time with glass windows. Seven of them, or six, depending on which sentence of our own History page you read. Twelve more went up on the lake bank below them, he bought others as they came up, and by 1930 he had 36. An advertisement from that year calls the place Fillenwarth’s Beach Cottages, and the Spirit Lake Beacon was still calling it that in 1968. None of them had air conditioning. A.T.’s position was that the cottages were “air conditioned by God.”

Sadie did the laundry, the reservations and the front desk, which by any modern count is three jobs. Their son Kenneth was born here, on the property, in 1924. He grew up building docks and teaching guests to ski, practiced law in Estherville with his wife Ruth, and helped his father run the resort every summer. The rest of Ken’s story, including Red’s Restaurant and the french fries he called “money orders,” is on our History page.

What did the 1968 tornado do to Fillenwarth Beach?

Around 7:30 on the evening of Thursday, June 13, 1968, a storm carrying tornadoes crossed from Osceola County into Dickinson County, cutting a swath the local papers put at nearly three miles wide. It reached the Arnolds Park lakefront at about 7:45. The Spirit Lake Beacon, Milford Mail and Lake Park News all reported the damage the following week, and Dickinson County Emergency Management keeps their accounts together. The Milford Mail’s line about us was short: “Fillenwarth Beach cottages were virtually blown away.”

It took most of the rental cottages on the Main Beach. Two buildings were left standing with only minor damage: the new office, finished in the spring of 1966, and Old Faithful. Sadie had died in December 1964, the year work on that office began, and never saw it finished.

The tornado did not stop at us. Five upper units of the Parkview Motel were destroyed, and the roof came off the Roof Garden ballroom at the amusement park. KICD in Spencer broadcast the warning and the town sirens sounded, and the papers credited that system with the fact that nobody died. Okoboji Magazine’s look back at the storm has the wider picture, including at least 350 damaged farms.

A.T. was 80 when it hit. Construction on a replacement started that fall: a large chateau building on the Main Beach, ready for guests in the spring of 1969. It is still there, the Chateau building beside the indoor pool. A.T. died in December 1971.

How did the resort end up with four properties?

By buying nearby resorts, mostly in the 1970s. In 1974 the family bought the Parkview Motel, which had lost five upper units in the same tornado, and it became South Beach. In 1978 they bought Gateswood Resort, across the road from the Main Beach, and it became Cottage Colony. Add North Beach, two blocks up the shore, and those are the four properties guests know now.

Old Faithful changed jobs in the same decade. The cottage with no windows became the indoor pool at the Main Beach, which it still is. If you have swum there, you have been inside the oldest building on the Main Beach.

We have been building ever since, a few units at a time. North Beach Chalets 155 and 156 were added in 1991. Cottages 412, 413 and 414 were rebuilt from the ground up in 1999 and now have mobility features, listed on our accessibility page. And in 1998 the Main Beach sea wall, built in 1938, came out and the Seawalk went in, with lounges for the sunset and gas grills for the family barbecue.

Where did the Sun Runners come from?

Arkansas. The family went down to the Kenner Boat Works in Knoxville, Arkansas, test drove the builder’s own boat, the Suwannee, and told Kenner how it could be built to carry guests better. Kenner built one to order in 1989, and Sun Runner I came north and was christened here.

In 1992 it caught fire, an electrical fire while it sat in its hoist. The Suwannee, the boat it had been modeled on, then made the trip north itself and became Sun Runner II. Since 1993 both boats have gone out daily, weather permitting, and they still do. Both are 49 feet.

That first season with two boats was the summer of the 1993 flood. The rains that caused it began on June 30 and kept on through mid-July, and there was a no-wake zone around the Okobojis. With the lake held to no-wake, the Sun Runner cruises became the social event on an eerily quiet lake. They still run 45 minutes around West Lake with a drink and some cheese and crackers, included with every stay along with the rest of our complimentary activities. If you want the parts of the lake’s history that are not about us, the History Cruise, on the deck boat, covers those.

Where can you still see the history on the property?

Most of it. Six of these ten are on the Main Beach, so if you are staying there, you can see them without leaving. Here is the property in the order it became ours, which is not the order you will walk it:

Year it arrived What Where to find it
1918 Old Faithful, the first cottage Main Beach, now the indoor pool
1966 The office Main Beach, where you check in
1969 The Chateau building, built after the tornado Main Beach, beside the indoor pool
1974 The former Parkview Motel South Beach
1978 The former Gateswood Resort Cottage Colony, across the road
1989 Sun Runner I The Main Beach Dock
1991 Chalets 155 and 156 North Beach, across the road
1993 Sun Runner II, formerly the Suwannee The Main Beach Dock
1998 The Seawalk, replacing the 1938 sea wall Main Beach, along the water
1999 Cottages 412, 413 and 414, rebuilt Cottage Colony

The 1930 advertisement and a photograph of the beach around 1950 are on the History page. If you are new to the lake itself, our guide to West Lake Okoboji explains what makes this one different.

FAQ

When was Fillenwarth Beach founded?

The family uses 1918, the year A.T. Fillenwarth built the first cottage according to the resort’s own history. Other printed sources give 1917 and 1919, and the resort’s FAQ concedes “1918 or 1919 (none of us were alive then).” By any of them it is more than a century old.

Was Fillenwarth Beach hit by the 1968 Okoboji tornado?

Yes. The tornado of June 13, 1968 demolished most of the rental cottages on the Main Beach. Only the office, finished in 1966, and Old Faithful, the original cottage, were left standing. The chateau building that replaced the cottages opened in the spring of 1969. Nobody in the area was killed.

What is Old Faithful?

The first cottage A.T. Fillenwarth built, around 1918, with awnings and screens instead of windows. It survived the 1968 tornado and was converted into the indoor pool at the Main Beach in the 1970s.

Who owns Fillenwarth Beach?

Lynn Fillenwarth, the founder’s granddaughter, who has run it since her father Ken’s death in 2014. It has been owned and operated by the same family for its entire history.

Where were the Sun Runner boats built?

By the Kenner Boat Works in Knoxville, Arkansas. Sun Runner I was built to order for the resort in 1989. After an electrical fire aboard it in 1992, Kenner’s own boat, the Suwannee, came north and became Sun Runner II. Both have gone out daily, weather permitting, since 1993.

The 1966 office reopens May 1, 2027, and the season runs to September 19. Call (712) 332-5646 or toll free (800) 332-7236, or send the reservations form. Someone who knows all 38 unit types will answer.